Closet candy sizing- Nell help lol

Hey everyone who shops at closet candy-

Here's my issue- I found a few loose/ hopefully forgiving shirts but not sure what size to get. I was always a small then I had kids. I have a narrow frame and super skinny arms. Now I have a 34 size band up top with not much to fill in a bra with lol- and I still look super pregnant - as in people congratulate me. All the time. Picture a pear, with toothpick arms and popsicle stick thighs and toothpicks again from the knees down.

Do you think I should get medium in these shirts or small?
My inclination is for the medium but do you think the shoulders and arms gonna be too loose?

Also for returns- I see that I'd have to pay for shipping- can I send back through regular mail or do I have to go to ups or FedEx? And no refunds just store credit...not crazy about that cuz if their clothes don't fit me I don't want to have 100$ store credit that I'll never use

Any advice?
I'll call the 800number but tomorrow but was hoping for quick help

Message edited 10/1/2017 8:21:15 PM.

Re: Closet candy sizing- Nell help lol

What do the fit notes on the shirts say? Does it say generous fit or runs true to size etc?

I once sized up on something that said generous fit and it ended up being a little too big.

If it says loose/generous/relaxed fit get your true size.

If not go up to the medium.

As far as returns yes, it's a pain in the A with the store credit only. Annoying. You can probably ship back via mail....I don't see why not