Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I have been getting zero sleep lately and have dark circles under my eyes....

I went to sephora and they recommended the smashbox conceler and I dont like it. I actually like a maybelline one that I got on a whim better.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

i've tried so many, and i keep going back to MAC studio finish concealer spf 35. It's $16.50 and lasts me months. it comes in a little compact like their shadows.

I just recently tried the smashbox one sephora suggested (too cakey) and Benefit's bo-oing (too dry, and i'm between shades and didn't want to buy 2 and mix), and the MAC is by far my favorite.

Message edited 2/7/2011 8:27:43 PM.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I am swearing by ELF apricot correcting concealer...I got it as a stocking stuffer from my friend and I am loving it. No caking and totally brightens my eyes!

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I use one from Clinique and have been happy with it (and i tend to think that EVERYTHING cakes on my face, if that helps lol)

I just got the under eye brightener from Smashbox- i feel that it does brighten and adds a shimmer that i love, but i have still been using the clinique under that. (the smashbox one i got isn't a concealer, i dont think)

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I went through this & tried so many last year!

I agree with Shorty--Mac studio finish. It also helps that the NW25 is a perfect color match for me.

I liked Clinique All About eyes, but the colors weren't right for me.

I didn't like Boing either--too dry.

I also like Laura Mercier Secret Concealer. It looks a little too peachy, but it balances the purple out. I use that under my foundation, or the Mac one over it, or if I am not wearing foundation, or both if it is a really bad day!

Make Up forever HD (in the pen) was good too, but I felt like I went through it very quickly.

Also Neutrogena eye brightener in a pen is also good.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I am obsessed with my concealer. its cle de peau in the beige color. I have had horrible dark circles my whole life and a little bit of this makes them so much better. its expensive but lasts a long time and totally worth it.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

Time balm, they sell it in Sephora but not all locations. They def have it at Roosevelt Field.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I really like Mac moisturecover and Smashbox High Definition Concealer.
I am planning on buying Mac studio finish next week bc I hear really good things about it and I hear it lasts longer when you put it on.

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

I've always used Lancome Photogenic Concealer

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

Re: Under eye concealer that doesnt cake?

Posted by Shorty

Posted by tourist

I agree with Shorty--Mac studio finish. It also helps that the NW25 is a perfect color match for me.

I'm NW20