Catholic Schools (1-8) near or in Herricks SD

I'll be moving to Searingtown soon so when it was Catholic Schools week, I visited the local schools hoping to choose one for my DD who will be a 1st grader in September.
PLEASE help me choose a school !!!!
I would love/appreciate any feedback both good & bad.

1. I saw St Peters but it was a bit out of the way, didn't really click.

2. St Mary's was amazing! I was hoping for a little larger class size but other than that, they impressed both my DH & I. But it was most $$$ so


3. St Aiden's seemed like the perfect fit. But when I re-visited last week, they were full. So she's on the waiting list.

Does anyone have any other suggestions? Maybe St Anne's in Garden City??

TIA!

Re: Catholic Schools (1-8) near or in Herricks SD

There is also St. Joseph's in Garden City. Not sure of their tuition though. I do know St. Mary's is one of the more expensive..


What about Notre Dame School in New Hyde Park?

Here's a list of the Catholic school in the Diocese of RVC:


LINK to schools

Re: Catholic Schools (1-8) near or in Herricks SD

Re: Catholic Schools (1-8) near or in Herricks SD

Thanks for the input. I've looked the list up/down a 100 times throughout the last year.
I think pretty much you get the same education in most of the schools.. I was looking more for info like that strong sense of family/community/involvement.
I'm seriously considering driving her back & forth to her school here in Queens because our current school fulfills this .... my DH thinks I'm a loon.