LIFamilies.com - Long Island, NY


RSS
Articles Business Directory Blog Real Estate Community Forum Shop My Family Contests

Log In Chat Index Search Rules Lingo Create Account

Quick navigation:   

Do You Believe Him?

Forum Opinion Poll
No 36 52.17%
Yes 5 7.25%
Maybe 1 1.45%
Not Sure 7 10.14%
Didn't Watch 20 28.99%
 

Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

JennChris
life moves fast

Member since 5/05

4225 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

What really got me when he was upset that her Mom was yelling at him ' Where's my Daughter?" of course she was, her daughter was MISSING... he just seemed to have NO feeling!

Posted 2/24/06 10:27 PM
 

MRSJLK
LIF Toddler

Member since 10/05

472 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by Tumbalina

Posted by hmpena

I watched it... I definitely think he is hiding stuff.



he's a lying piece of sheet! Chat Icon



Agreed!!!!!! Chat Icon

Posted 2/24/06 10:27 PM
 

Salason

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

he seemed robotic. almost like he convinced himself his lies were true

Posted 2/24/06 10:27 PM
 

peabody
Love green icing!!!

Member since 5/05

4691 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Was he born in Aruba?

I watched it and I am really unsure how I felt about him. I feel for Natalie's mom.

Posted 2/24/06 10:47 PM
 

megsmom
#2 on the way!

Member since 5/05

1723 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

I wonder if and when they will replay it I would have liked to watch it. My brother was telling me about it.. he said he wasn't to convinced by him and that he didnt believe him either..

Posted 2/24/06 11:16 PM
 

LAMGAJ28
.

Member since 10/05

6039 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by andri

I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he definetly had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????



I'm so surprised you think there are not a lot of places to hide a body....
We rented a jeep while we were there in January...we went also where the water is rough...If you get thrown in there...you are gone....and they have all these big rocks on that side as well.....
On our way back, we took another road that wasn't that populated.....I definitely think a native from the island that knows well..can dig up and bury a body.....
I personally do think that they can definitely make someone disappear.

Message edited 2/25/2006 10:37:36 PM.

Posted 2/25/06 10:35 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by andri

Posted by Stefanie

What the hell would she want to see sharks for anyway...especially at night? You can't see anything at night.

Also, I don't believe him that he's never gotten a girl drunk to take advantage of her.

He's a saint...puleeze!!!Chat Icon

Why did he move all the way over to Holland?Chat Icon



Aruba was a Dutch colony up until 1998.. it did & still has strong ties with HOLLAND.
It is totally normal for Arubean kids to go to the Netherlands to get higher education since the highest form of education on the island is H.S.
Thats why he went to Holland.

I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he definetly had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????




that's CRAP IMO!! He FLED to Holland to get away from this mess!!!! he didn't go there for a 'higher education'...i don't buy that for a split second!

he's a lying piece of sh!t and knows more than he's saying! c'mon....tooo many lies! i hope he gets what he deserves, as well as his 'friends'!!!!Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/06 11:18 PM
 

LisaW
Time for me to FLY!

Member since 5/05

13199 total posts

Name:
Did I ever tell you that I hate people?

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by andri

Posted by Stefanie

What the hell would she want to see sharks for anyway...especially at night? You can't see anything at night.

Also, I don't believe him that he's never gotten a girl drunk to take advantage of her.

He's a saint...puleeze!!!Chat Icon

Why did he move all the way over to Holland?Chat Icon



Aruba was a Dutch colony up until 1998.. it did & still has strong ties with HOLLAND.
It is totally normal for Arubean kids to go to the Netherlands to get higher education since the highest form of education on the island is H.S.
Thats why he went to Holland.

I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he definetly had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????




that's CRAP IMO!! He FLED to Holland to get away from this mess!!!! he didn't go there for a 'higher education'...i don't buy that for a split second!

he's a lying piece of sh!t and knows more than he's saying! c'mon....tooo many lies! i hope he gets what he deserves, as well as his 'friends'!!!!Chat Icon



I agree. I remember reading that he originally planned to go to college in the states.

Posted 2/25/06 11:20 PM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by andri

Hmmmm.... innocent until proven guilty,no?
There is NO evidence to prove that he had a motive or that he killed her.
I don't "like" him but I also don't believe he killed her. Just my gut feeling backed up by the lack of evidence and by all the foolish mistakes SHE made.


then why did he and his friends feel the need to LIE AND LIE AND LIE...when they were looking for her

INNOCENT people have no need to LIEChat Icon

innocent ...PUHLEEEEEEEEEZE....

Posted 2/26/06 1:23 PM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by andri

Oh he made them also..but come on, just what were HER intentions when she got into a car with 3 guys (2 of whom she never saw) in a foreign country? Did she think they were a Taxi service?
Everyone keeps painting a picture of a perfect teenager- which she was not...& "overlooking" all her actions leading up to the dissapearance.


Posted by andri
I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he definetly had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????



Wow...i am sorry but i am absolutely sickened by your comments...

You sit there and say innocent until proven guilty yet pass judgements on a person who probably is DEAD...

Can you say you know ANYTHING about her?
She was a stupid teenager...yea maybe.
But to sit there and question her and what she did to cause whatever happened to her SICKENS ME. I am sure she had no intentions of disappearing, of being killed, of never returning home, of never seeing or hearing from her family ever again...I AM SURE she didn't sit there and think of these things that night. She was a kid. Someone who possibly never thought of the BAD things that could happen to her. She was INNOCENT IMO.
Does that make her the "perfect person" no...but that doesn't mean ANYTHING nor did it mean that she deserved what happened to her.
And for this one mistake...that possibly has taken her life....YOU JUDGE HER...You sit there and say well...it is her fault too? O M G

WHAT wE can judge that piece of crap liar...because he is doind the talking and the LYING.

Did you think of the possibility that she was drugged?

And to be quiet honest... you may have been to Aruba 2xs but expert that does not make you.
And there is a BIG body of water to put a body if need be...Chat Icon

Message edited 2/26/2006 1:49:10 PM.

Posted 2/26/06 1:29 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by Redhead

Posted by andri
Oh he made them also..but come on, just what were HER intentions when she got into a car with 3 guys (2 of whom she never saw) in a foreign country? Did she think they were a Taxi service?
Everyone keeps painting a picture of a perfect teenager- which she was not...& "overlooking" all her actions leading up to the dissapearance.


Posted by andri
I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he definetly had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????



Wow...i am sorry but i am absolutely sickened by your comments...

You sit there and say innocent until proven guilty yet pass judgements on a person who probably is DEAD...

Can you say you know ANYTHING about her?
She was a stupid teenager...yea maybe.
But to sit there and question her and what she did to cause whatever happened to her SICKENS ME. I am sure she had no intentions of disappearing, of being killed, of never returning home, of never seeing or hearing from her family ever again...I AM SURE she didn't sit there and think of these things that night. She was a kid. Someone who possibly never thought of the BAD things that could happen to her. She was INNOCENT IMO.
Does that make her the "perfect person" no...but that doesn't mean ANYTHING nor did it mean that she deserved what happened to her.
And for this one mistake...that possibly has taken her life....YOU JUDGE HER...You sit there and say well...it is her fault too? O M G

WHAT wE can judge that piece of crap liar...because he is doind the talking and the LYING.

Did you think of the possibility that she was drugged?

And to be quiet honest... you may have been to Aruba 2xs but expert that does not make you.
And there is a BIG body of water to put a body if need be...Chat Icon




OMG THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!!

I couldn't agree more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted 2/26/06 8:53 PM
 

DebG
Pick a cause & stand up for it

Member since 5/05

18602 total posts

Name:
The cure IS worse!

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

sounds like the argument about a girl wearing skimpy clothes desrves to get raped
Chat Icon
sicking ignorance.

Posted 2/26/06 8:54 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by DebG

sounds like the argument about a girl wearing skimpy clothes desrves to get raped
Chat Icon
sicking ignorance.




Chat Icon

Posted 2/26/06 8:55 PM
 

reggie
I love my boys!!

Member since 5/05

8044 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

My husband's law firm is representing the Hollaways(sp?) in the civil suit.

Posted 2/26/06 9:22 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by DebG

sounds like the argument about a girl wearing skimpy clothes desrves to get raped
Chat Icon
sicking ignorance.



Exactly - that's how come they made Rape Shield Laws!!

Posted 2/26/06 9:22 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by regi

My husband's law firm is representing the Hollaways(sp?) in the civil suit.



Chat Icon kudos to him and his firm!!! I hope the case is settled in their favor!!! Chat Icon

Posted 2/26/06 9:47 PM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by regi

My husband's law firm is representing the Hollaways(sp?) in the civil suit.



Not that he is anything at all but i hope they nail that MOFO to the wall

Posted 2/26/06 10:09 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by Redhead

Posted by andri
Oh he made them also..but come on, just what were HER intentions when she got into a car with 3 guys (2 of whom she never saw) in a foreign country? Did she think they were a Taxi service?
Everyone keeps painting a picture of a perfect teenager- which she was not...& "overlooking" all her actions leading up to the disappearance.


Posted by andri
I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he Definitely had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????



Wow...i Am sorry but I am absolutely sickened by your comments...

You sit there and say innocent until proven guilty yet pass judgements on a person who probably is DEAD...

Can you say you know ANYTHING about her?
She was a stupid teenager...yea maybe.
But to sit there and question her and what she did to cause whatever happened to her SICKENS ME. I am sure she had no intentions of disappearing, of being killed, of never returning home, of never seeing or hearing from her family ever again...I AM SURE she didn't sit there and think of these things that night. She was a kid. Someone who possibly never thought of the BAD things that could happen to her. She was INNOCENT IMO.
Does that make her the "perfect person" no...but that doesn't mean ANYTHING nor did it mean that she deserved what happened to her.
And for this one mistake...that possibly has taken her life....YOU JUDGE HER...You sit there and say well...it is her fault too? O M G

WHAT wE can judge that piece of crap liar...because he is doind the talking and the LYING.

Did you think of the possibility that she was drugged?

And to be quiet honest... you may have been to Aruba 2xs but expert that does not make you.
And there is a BIG body of water to put a body if need be...Chat Icon




OMG THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!!

I couldn't agree more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Lets not forgot that Natalee was not from a big city here. Chat Icon How dumb and ignorant you have to be to basically say someone deserves to be killed Chat Icon

Posted 2/27/06 9:47 AM
 

andri
LIF Infant

Member since 11/05

241 total posts

Name:

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

Posted by june262004

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by Redhead

Posted by andri
Oh he made them also..but come on, just what were HER intentions when she got into a car with 3 guys (2 of whom she never saw) in a foreign country? Did she think they were a Taxi service?
Everyone keeps painting a picture of a perfect teenager- which she was not...& "overlooking" all her actions leading up to the disappearance.


Posted by andri
I've been to Aruba 14 times..2xs since Natalie.
I am very familiar with the island , there are NOT many places to hide a body..where under a cactus?...he Definitely had intentions with "getting busy" with her..as she did with him. As for what happened after.... ?????????



Wow...i Am sorry but I am absolutely sickened by your comments...

You sit there and say innocent until proven guilty yet pass judgements on a person who probably is DEAD...

Can you say you know ANYTHING about her?
She was a stupid teenager...yea maybe.
But to sit there and question her and what she did to cause whatever happened to her SICKENS ME. I am sure she had no intentions of disappearing, of being killed, of never returning home, of never seeing or hearing from her family ever again...I AM SURE she didn't sit there and think of these things that night. She was a kid. Someone who possibly never thought of the BAD things that could happen to her. She was INNOCENT IMO.
Does that make her the "perfect person" no...but that doesn't mean ANYTHING nor did it mean that she deserved what happened to her.
And for this one mistake...that possibly has taken her life....YOU JUDGE HER...You sit there and say well...it is her fault too? O M G

WHAT wE can judge that piece of crap liar...because he is doind the talking and the LYING.

Did you think of the possibility that she was drugged?

And to be quiet honest... you may have been to Aruba 2xs but expert that does not make you.
And there is a BIG body of water to put a body if need be...Chat Icon




OMG THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!!

I couldn't agree more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Lets not forgot that Natalee was not from a big city here. Chat Icon How dumb and ignorant you have to be to basically say someone deserves to be killed Chat Icon




OMG Ladies!! I just happened to look back at this post & notice how everyone was so fired up!

Shitt!!! I didn't mean I believe him totally..NOR DID I SAY SHE DESERVED TO BE KILLED ..
someone dissagrees with you guys and right away I'm dumb & ignorant???
I said "innocent until proven guilty" because last I looked,those are our American standards? unless things have changed since I've studied Criminal Justice. Sheesh! This case is so emotional because there is so much hearsay,the story was changed X amount of times..by the accused,by the authorities.

No,I am not an authority on Aruba & I have not been there twice in total...twice since her dissapearance,14 times in total..we have timesharing,my family is always there (my sister is there as we speak!). I am VERY familiar with the island..it is small,basically flat and almost impossible to dig,it is not regular soil. It is sickening that because of ONE case,ppl would actually think of boycotting..then imagine what the fate of NY would be!

Sure,there are rough seas on the other side of the island,even by the lighthouse...if she was thrown into sea,wouldn't some fragment of her,her clothing wash ashore or possibly get cought on the sharp rock? That island was combed over several times by authorities there,authorities from the US,local volunteers..even the sea was searched. The people of the island were given off time from work to search for the missing girl...when was the last time any of us went searching for anyone here in NY?

& guess what??? I am NOT sorry for any of my comments.. I have no remorse for someones bad judgement...how can any of you refute that she put herself in the line of danger????? I am sure that there is so much more to this story that none of us know:
-Natalee also called her mom that last day to ask if she can extend her trip,her mom said no.
-she had run away on other occasions(once while on a trip to the Dominican Republic)

Maybe her life wasn't such a happy one as was painted. Could she have run away again? Comitted suicide?

The original posters on the island said "Missing Girl" her pic .. & Natalee, mommy is here on the island,call me at this # even her mother thought she ran away again. I saw those posters,do a search,maybe it comes up..or if you are interested..a HUGE thread is dedicated to her & any updates on aruba.com.

I'm not freakin' inhumane,its sad & I'm sorry for all involved that it seems at this point..it'll just go on as an unsolved case,as there are THOUSANDS every year here in the US.
If yo can make an argument for her lack of judgement by saying "she's a teenager,she made some mistakes"..same could be said for Juron the teenaged gigalo he & his friends lied in the past 'cause they were caught off guard. If they planned & murdered her,wouldn't they be like "Ok,this is the story if we get caught or if they ask us" plus no DNA evidence anywhere...no evidence at all?

Flame if you must,I'd rather have a conversation about the case than what was she wearing,what school she attended..blahblah irrelavant.

Posted 2/27/06 1:38 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Did Anyone Watch Last Night Dateline about Natalie Holloway?

andri...what got me 'fired up' is the fact that you seem to defend more the accused, then the possible victim in this case!! add to that the insensitive remarks about her judgement, and it just makes for an unnerving read.
you have "no remorse" for her bad judgement??? but do you have remorse in your heart at the possiblity that b/c of her bad judgement, she may have been killed??? shouldn't defending aruba take a backseat to this heartwrenching possibility?????

also add to that your constant need to remind everyone how often you've visited the island, and how you're "very familiar" with aruba. so what. so are the locals who live there. "where there's a will, there's a way" is how the saying goes, so if they wanted to be rid of her body, they'd find a way to do it.

i ask you this, how would you feel about your precious aruba, if it turned out that the LOCALS from the island were responsible for what happened to Natalie?? if they in fact did get rid of her body?

as for joran....this kid knows more than he's saying. plain and simple. he left his shoes on the beach?? why? b/c he "just did"...i don't buy that for a bleeping second. something happened. he panicked. which is WHY he FLED to Holland! not b/c his brain was itching for more knowlegde!! that's a load of CR@P!!!

and so they have a HUGE thread dedicated to her on aruba.com! in doing this, they're being proactive, and not giving up on this case. that's good.

i have very close friends that go to aruba every year, for the past 10 years. their entire family goes! mothers, fathers, uncles, aunts, cousins.....all ages...
well, this particular year, something bad happened!!
i won't get into details, but because of the lack security and/or training of security personnel, a MAJOR screw up occurred...attornies here in the states were contacted...corporate office of that hotel was called, and within 24 hours, several changes were made to that particular hotel's policies!!

Message edited 2/27/2006 5:51:39 PM.

Posted 2/27/06 4:00 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Van Der Sloot...speaks about Natalie Holloway and that fateful night...... LAMGAJ28 2/23/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Need help in finding a watch for my dh...(edited) LIPrincess 9/7/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
DS won't sleep during the day or night... preciouslove 9/7/06 30 Parenting
Did anyone watch 20/20 and dateline tonight? Beth 8/25/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Did anyone watch the Hallmark Movie last night? FelAndJon 1/30/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
Did anyone watch Intervention last night? missus-hbradio 1/9/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
 
Quick navigation:   
Currently 423209 users on the LIFamilies.com Chat
New Businesses
1 More Rep
Carleton Hall of East Islip
J&A Building Services
LaraMae Health Coaching
Sonic Wellness
Julbaby Photography LLC
Ideal Uniforms
Teresa Geraghty Photography
Camelot Dream Homes
Long Island Wedding Boutique
MB Febus- Rodan & Fields
Camp Harbor
Market America-Shop.com
ACM Basement Waterproofing
Travel Tom

      Follow LIWeddings on Facebook

      Follow LIFamilies on Twitter
Long Island Bridal Shows