Torn. Help with 2 shoes for bridesmaid dress? [poll]

I'm a size 10 shoe, and must have a short heel due to the length of the dress. When I walk, you will see my toes. The wedding is in May so we're all doing open toe.

BM dress, the color is actually darker than that picture:



(I think it's funny that you can see the model's feet - I'm not going THAT short)

So here are shoe choices:

Choice #1

64 reviews, 5 stars. Most reviews list that it is wide in the front and extremely comfortable. I think it would look ok on my big feet but is a little plain. The heel is wider in the back, for good support.




Choice #2

17 reviews, 5 stars. One person complained that the shoe was tight in front and hurt their feet. One said the shoe catches on fabric. But I like the style a lot more and think it would be more flattering.

Re: Torn. Help with 2 shoes for bridesmaid dress? [poll]

Tough choice, they are both really nice. Something special about #2 though!

Re: Torn. Help with 2 shoes for bridesmaid dress? [poll]

Number one because they look so much more comfortable and you will be on your feet a lot as a bridesmaid. As a guest I would have said number 2. I am also a size 10 shoe. Where are these from?

Message edited 1/28/2012 5:28:28 PM.

Re: Torn. Help with 2 shoes for bridesmaid dress? [poll]

Neck and neck so far! I will be standing for the ceremony, pictures obviously, but the bride and I have already planned on bringing slippers to the reception.

Here is the link for choice 1: http://www.zappos.com/david-tate-beverly-navy-satin

And choice 2:

http://www.zappos.com/j-renee-rosina-navy

I am a fashion nightmare, so you may be seeing more threads from me on everything from hair to makeup to jewelry.

Re: Torn. Help with 2 shoes for bridesmaid dress? [poll]

The logical side of me says to go with comfort and choice #1, but choice #2 is ! Any chance you could order both to see how they feel on you and then return the pair you don't choose?