Re: Weekly Meghan bashing thread (idol)

Posted by HillW9608

And WTH was she doing.. I didnt get the whole arm flapping thing

Re: Weekly Meghan bashing thread (idol)

SO FREAKIN HAPPY SHE IS GONE! Ugh she cant sing for teh life of her! And that whole caw caw thing WHAT?? WEIRD GIRL! Theres places fo rpeople like her. I believe they have white padded walls!

Re: Weekly Meghan bashing thread (idol)

yeah, I felt REALLY uncomfortable watching her this week. And i'm one of those rare people who actually does like her unique 40's style voice (if only she'd pick the right songs that flattered this voice once in a while). But that dancing - oh my. I always got really awkward when she'd get up there and start twisting her hips and flailing her arms unrhythmically to the music. I don't understand why she never watched herself on the replay and thought "hey, I'm a white girl with no rhythm, maybe i should just stand still & hold the mic."

But anyway - yes, it was time for her go. And she made me feel ESPECIALLY uncomfortable last night when she did that "Caw, Caw" thing which i have still yet to understand. Plus she was acting way too happy as she sat there in the bottom 3 (I guess so not to show her true emotions) but it was just a little irritating cause you KNOW it's all fake. And then her horrible facial expressions ESPECIALLY when it was her & Anoop standing there and Ryan was about to say who was out. Ugh. Anoop was taking it all seriously and she was doing some goofy ugly face. Irritated the crap outta me. But I did feel bad when Simon told her that they wouldn't save her no matter what. I mean, yeah, it's good to tell her BEFORE the performance so she can relax, but he just said it so mean (thus is SIMON tho. lol)

ok, my bashing is now complete


ETA - I'm really hoping that Scott will be next to go. I really do not enjoy watching him at all. In fact, I don't know anybody who does. Why is he still there and not even in the bottom 3? Crazy to me. He's not HORRIBLE, but definitely not as good as the others.

Message edited 4/2/2009 11:57:57 AM.

Re: Weekly Meghan bashing thread (idol)

Posted by RockysGirl

yeah, I felt REALLY uncomfortable watching her this week. And i'm one of those rare people who actually does like her unique 40's style voice (if only she'd pick the right songs that flattered this voice once in a while). But that dancing - oh my. I always got really awkward when she'd get up there and start twisting her hips and flailing her arms unrhythmically to the music. I don't understand why she never watched herself on the replay and thought "hey, I'm a white girl with no rhythm, maybe i should just stand still & hold the mic."

But anyway - yes, it was time for her go. And she made me feel ESPECIALLY uncomfortable last night when she did that "Caw, Caw" thing which i have still yet to understand. Plus she was acting way too happy as she sat there in the bottom 3 (I guess so not to show her true emotions) but it was just a little irritating cause you KNOW it's all fake. And then her horrible facial expressions ESPECIALLY when it was her & Anoop standing there and Ryan was about to say who was out. Ugh. Anoop was taking it all seriously and she was doing some goofy ugly face. Irritated the crap outta me. But I did feel bad when Simon told her that they wouldn't save her no matter what. I mean, yeah, it's good to tell her BEFORE the performance so she can relax, but he just said it so mean (thus is SIMON tho. lol)

ok, my bashing is now complete


ETA - I'm really hoping that Scott will be next to go. I really do not enjoy watching him at all. In fact, I don't know anybody who does. Why is he still there and not even in the bottom 3? Crazy to me. He's not HORRIBLE, but definitely not as good as the others.

Re: Weekly Meghan bashing thread (idol)

Posted by Strawberry2468

Simon said he wouldnt save her b/c he didnt care...she said she "didnt care" about his criticisms the night before.

The caw thing is from when she sang rockin robin. She did that at the end.

I thought Scott was good in the beginning, but he is sorta boring. Too adult contemporty for my taste. I think he will stay for awhile for the sympathy vote.

I dont think Lil is as great as they keep saying. Maybe she is picking the wrong songs, but she is another one i find awkward.