White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Kinda had my heart set on White Post Farms, but her birthday is in February (I was considering waiting until spring, but now I'm not).

I know White Post does winter parties indoors, but (I know this may sound silly), I'm worried that the smell would be overbearing... lol I'm pregnant so guess I am over sensitive to those things.

But that would be my first choice.

Then I heard great things too about Pump it Up.

Has anyone been to a party at WP indoors? and/or a party at PIU?

Any feedback?

Thanks

Message edited 11/1/2010 11:11:41 AM.

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

For a 2 year old, I'd do WPF..

I've been to parties at both but I think that PIU is better for kids slightly older and WPF is fantastic ALL year round.. You won't feel jipped at all because it's indoors.. there is so much to do there..

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

We went to a party at WPF in late Novemeber and honestly, the smell was no worse than it is in the hot summer. I think it even smelled less. It is well ventilated. We had a great time even though it was indoors!!!

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

my 2yo had a ball at PIU in great neck

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

we went to one last feb - he was only 5 months - but he enjoyed it llots- they had a train ride, watched a robotic chicken??? show, pony rides, fed animals and gave animals milk, it moves around a lot and not in one spot too long so the smell was not too bad - oh he also got to pet a 2 week old goat - it was adorable - WPF works well if you have younger kids too - because beginner walkers would have trouble at a pump it up place - my little guy could not feed the animals but he loved looking at them and petting them - he loves animals - i thouht they did a great job and will definetly have my son's b-day there in the future

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

I think Pump it Up is better for the 4+ crowd. I'd do White Post for 2 year olds.

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Thanks everyone! I am definitely thinking WPF.

DD LOVES going there, between feeding the animals, riding the train and pony we can't get her out of there.

The kids range from 18 months to 6 years (alot of 3- 4 year olds though).

A friend actually told me about PUI after bringing her 18 month old to a party there and she said he loved it.

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

I think WPF is great for a two year old, but in my opinion, for the price of the party, i do not think it would be worth it of it was not outdoors.

A party for 20 kids and pizza for adults, with taxes /gratuity cost $980....

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Definitely WPF for a 2yo.

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

I had my girls 2 year old at White Post. It was the best party.

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

Re: White Post Farms or or Pump it Up for 2 yr old winter party?

it was indoors and heated. we were actually really warm. almost hot.