Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

My son's B-day party in in 2 weeks. The pizzaria I was using unexpectedly closed I need a Reasonable priced place that will deliver food to Levittown. 65 people including kids.

Are all Italian food places the same? I am not from NY!

Also would a hero be good also with the hot food? I am so confused!

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated thank you!!!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

I have never taken food out of here, but I have been to party's here and booked my group Christmas party here last year and the food was very good.

Ciminelli's

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

I live in Suffolk but just recently priced around diff pizzeria's and the price's were pretty much the same for the standard dishes (penna alla vodka/chicken franchese, etc)

I ended up getting the food from a place in North Babylon (not sure they would deliver to Levitown but you could always call) The food was AMAZING. The BEST catered food i think i ever had. The trays were packed too. I got a ton of compliments.

The place is called Nonna Bella's on Deer Park Ave. (it used to be Tina;s pizza for 20+ years) the phone # is 631 669 1250.

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

You should check out Division Ave Caterer's in Levittown. They have great heroes and we also did some hot trays that were excellent. We have used them a couple of times and been very happy!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

I highly recommend Piccolo's. They are in Bellmore but I'm sure they deliver to Levittown. I used them for my son's party and was very happy with them and they are reasonable.

A hero is always a good choice to go with the hot food.

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

If you are looking for AWESOME Italian Food, I highly, highly, highly recommend Mama Theresa's in East Meadow.

I'll put it this way--since leaving NY, their food is literally the *only* thing I miss about NY. When we're back for a visit, we go there at least 3 times!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

For the hero you should go to Division Avenue Deli.

I agree with Mama Theresa's - they are delish!

Also try pappalardos on Hicksville Rd
And, Phils Pizzeria on Hicksville Road.

Pizza King in East Meadow used to make delicious pizza but I haven't been there in ages!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

I would get a hero from Division Ave Deli and the hot food from Mama Teresa's...I LOVE their food!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

for catering we are all about guy anthony's.. we've used them COUNTLESS times and always get rave reviews.

Guy & Anthony can make anything- on the menu or off.

If you go with them, don't get packages, but get trays- it's much more affordable. They'll tell you howmuch you need for how many people.

We used them for DD's first b-day and had them make a menu that was all "cut free"- since I wasn't having seating for everyone, I needed foods that people could eat w/o cutting and trying to balance a plate on their lap- they came up with some great suggestions, and even made a few special things for the little ones!

Guy Anthony's

2208 Jerusalem Avenue
Merrick NY 11566
T: (516) 221-5555
F: (516) 221-5556

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

We've used Marsala in Massapequa. Food was great and they delivered to suffolk. So I imagine they would deliver Levittown.

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

I love Mama Theresa's as well!

Another option yummy and close that may deliver is Rosemarie's .

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

What about Domenico's? They are right in Levittown?

Ungle Giuseppe's is also great, they have a few locations...their food is fab!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

Awesome thanks for all your info!

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

Re: Help need catering for son's 1st b-day place I was using closed

Piesanos on hempstead tpke in east meadow!!! I used them for my engagement party, and my sis used for nephews christening... The food is soo good and soo reasonable in prie.