The crown of our chimney and some of the cement between the bricks needs to be repaired. We have had two chimney companies come to our home and both offered wildly different quotes to do the same job.

Of course, it sounds sensible to go with company #1, the company offering the cheaper quote. But they also told us we really need a new chimney liner which is a big expense. Company #2 told us we do not need a chimeny liner, so I feel as if they might be slightly more honest. Company #2 also seemed to do a much more thorough job with our chimney & flue inspections and cleaning.

So, I'm wondering if we go with the cheap company, will we regret it, is this a case of getting what you pay for, or is the more expensive company ripping us off?

So, if you have had similar work done, do you mind fming me and telling me what you paid? Guess I want to see which number seems to be more common. This is for crown and chimney repair as well as waterproofing.

I should add I've checked out both companies--both were recommended by people in our area and both are licensed and have no complaints on record.

TIA!