| Posted By |
Message |
| Pages: [1] 2 |
yankinmanc
Happy Days!
Member since 8/05 18208 total posts
Name:
|
Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Right. Thanksgiving. Religious holiday or not. I say NO. A big fat stonking NO.
Please...
|
Posted 11/21/07 6:39 AM  |
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource |
MissJones
I need a nap!
Member since 5/05 22136 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Not religious or it would be celebrated all over the world.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 6:43 AM |
| |
|
yankinmanc
Happy Days!
Member since 8/05 18208 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by MissJones
Not religious or it would be celebrated all over the world.
Very Very good point indeed. I might use that in my argument.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 6:45 AM |
| |
|
CathyB
Member since 5/05 19403 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Maybe it was for the Pilgrims? But sadly, not around for us to ask. Perhaps they sent a letter home and Jonty found it in the attic of the person you are debating.
ETA: Nevermind, I realized they were Dutch not British. Joke doesn't really work now.
Message edited 11/21/2007 6:49:07 AM.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 6:47 AM |
| |
|
Shorty
.
Member since 5/05 30390 total posts
Name:
really
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
nope. in fact, the Thanksgiving that we celebrate now (thanks to FDR) was actually promoted from old pilgrim holiday to national holiday for fiscal reasons!
|
| Posted 11/21/07 7:08 AM |
| |
|
yankinmanc
Happy Days!
Member since 8/05 18208 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by CathyB
Maybe it was for the Pilgrims? But sadly, not around for us to ask. Perhaps they sent a letter home and Jonty found it in the attic of the person you are debating.
ETA: Nevermind, I realized they were Dutch not British. Joke doesn't really work now.
I had to do a double take there... my friend Jenny calls my husband Jonty. No real reason...I think he reminds her of someone called Jonty.
Do you guys think that in the rest of America, ie outside of NY where people aren't as multi religioned, people see Thanksgiving as a religious holiday? Because in my argument on another forum people are saying that Thanksgiving is a day to thank god....
|
| Posted 11/21/07 7:09 AM |
| |
|
GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!
Member since 11/06 26792 total posts
Name:
Shawn
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
As with most questions.... "it depends"....
From Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving
The National Thanksgiving Proclamations
National Thanksgiving Proclamations proclaim thanks for God’s providence in the events of the nation and, as President Washington explained in his Thanksgiving Proclamation, "for the many signal favors of Almighty God" in the lives of the people.
As congress recognized the importance of Thanksgiving observance, President George Washington issued a national Thanksgiving Proclamation in 1789. He wrote, "Now therefore I do recommend and assign Thursday the 26th day of November next to be devoted by the People of these States to the service of that great and glorious Being, who is the beneficent Author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be—That we may then all unite in rendering unto him our sincere and humble thanks—for his kind care and protection of the People of this Country...for the signal and manifold mercies, and the favorable interpositions of his Providence which we experienced in the tranquility, union, and plenty, which we have since enjoyed...and also that we may then unite in most humbly offering our prayers and supplications to the great Lord and Ruler of Nations and beseech him to pardon our national and other transgressions—to enable us all, whether in public or private stations, to perform our several and relative duties properly and punctually...To promote the knowledge and practice of true religion and virtue, and the increase of science among them and us—and generally to grant unto all Mankind such a degree of temporal prosperity as he alone knows to be best."
In 1789 Washington designated a national thanksgiving holiday for the newly ratified Constitution, specifically so that the people may thank God for "affording them an opportunity peaceably to establish a form of government for their safety and happiness" and for having "been enabled to establish constitutions of government for our safety and happiness, and particularly the national One now lately instituted, for the civil and religious liberty with which we are blessed... "
President Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a Federal holiday as a "prayerful day of Thanksgiving" on the last Thursday in November. Since then every U.S. President has always made an official Thanksgiving Proclamation on behalf of the nation. President Franklin D. Roosevelt set the date for Thanksgiving to the fourth Thursday of November in 1939 (approved by Congress in 1941).
Technically, the Federal holiday is not religious, and it's founded on giving thanks for the harvest. However, most people thank God for the harvest bounty, making it religious.
I don't consider it a religious holiday. It's just a time to be thankful for everything and everyone we have.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 7:19 AM |
| |
|
GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!
Member since 1/07 14818 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
officially not a religious holiday
but my family always attends church bc we are thanking God for all that He has given us.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 7:22 AM |
| |
|
maybebaby
LIF Adult
Member since 11/05 6870 total posts
Name:
Maureen
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
People of all cultures/religions celebrate it...
One can definitely add their own sense of religion to it...we always say a prayer before we eat to thank god...BUT obviously don't have to.
It's just a day to be thankful for what we have. You could be completley atheist but still feel thankful, that is my rationale!
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:05 AM |
| |
|
BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here
Member since 5/07 8274 total posts
Name:
BunnyWife
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by maybebaby
It's just a day to be thankful for what we have. You could be completley atheist but still feel thankful, that is my rationale!
My husband is an atheist and celebrates so, at least in his mind, not a religious holiday
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:12 AM |
| |
|
JP826
=)
Member since 9/06 10903 total posts
Name:
Me!! All about ME!
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Nope. As American as they come.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:14 AM |
| |
|
2BEANS
wow time is going fast.
Member since 9/07 16106 total posts
Name:
Tina
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Not religious. Its a National holiday
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:22 AM |
| |
|
MegZee
My bunny
Member since 5/06 8777 total posts
Name:
Meaghan
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
no - it was to celebrate the first harvest (but it might have coincided with a Pilgrim Holiday?)
but then again the first settlers left England/Europe to avoid religious persecution, so I think there were a few religions that were here.
and tthen the Europeans gave the Native Americans syphallus...
Canada also has a Thanksgiving, but its earlier in the year.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:31 AM |
| |
|
yankinmanc
Happy Days!
Member since 8/05 18208 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
When people ask me about Thanksgiving and what it is, as many Brits do...I have been asked twice today.
I usually tell them the usual bumpf and then I tell them that we repaid the native americans by raping their women, stealing their land and forcing them to live on reservations....
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:36 AM |
| |
|
QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!
Member since 5/05 13659 total posts
Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
officially not a religious holiday
they do have mass tomorrow morning (which we attend) but it's not a holy day of obligation
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:37 AM |
| |
|
Ginger123
Sooo happy
Member since 8/07 1235 total posts
Name:
dana
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
American
|
| Posted 11/21/07 8:42 AM |
| |
|
lucyloo
nope
Member since 1/06 9758 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
not at all
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:18 AM |
| |
|
SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!
Member since 3/06 32345 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
it's as American as apple pie 
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:19 AM |
| |
|
june262004
But I love the Snow!
Member since 5/05 15379 total posts
Name:
Kristin
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Not religious..
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:20 AM |
| |
|
SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!
Member since 3/06 32345 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by racheeeee
When people ask me about Thanksgiving and what it is, as many Brits do...I have been asked twice today.
I usually tell them the usual bumpf and then I tell them that we repaid the native americans by raping their women, stealing their land and forcing them to live on reservations....
as opposed to the Birtish Empire doing this all over the world for 100's of years 
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:22 AM |
| |
|
KGools
Happy
Member since 9/06 9532 total posts
Name:
Kim
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Nope not at all.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:23 AM |
| |
|
PotofLuck06
Our Baby Boy Is Here!!!
Member since 11/06 13241 total posts
Name:
Betsy
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Not religious.
The US celebrates it as a combination of customs during a time of bleakness in our early history.
Canda celebrates as well, but earlier as a comemeration(sp?) of the explorers who founded passageways and other settlements.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:24 AM |
| |
|
PattyK
Lovin my hubby!
Member since 10/07 2901 total posts
Name:
Patricia
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
As far as I know it is not a religious holiday.
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:26 AM |
| |
|
BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here
Member since 5/07 8274 total posts
Name:
BunnyWife
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by SweetestOfPeas
Posted by racheeeee
When people ask me about Thanksgiving and what it is, as many Brits do...I have been asked twice today.
I usually tell them the usual bumpf and then I tell them that we repaid the native americans by raping their women, stealing their land and forcing them to live on reservations....
as opposed to the Birtish Empire doing this all over the world for 100's of years
Good point. No major empire at any time in history hasn't been guilty of this unfortunately
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:27 AM |
| |
|
SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!
Member since 3/06 32345 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Settle this argument for me re Thanksgiving
Posted by BunnyWife
Posted by SweetestOfPeas
Posted by racheeeee
When people ask me about Thanksgiving and what it is, as many Brits do...I have been asked twice today.
I usually tell them the usual bumpf and then I tell them that we repaid the native americans by raping their women, stealing their land and forcing them to live on reservations....
as opposed to the Birtish Empire doing this all over the world for 100's of years
Good point. No major empire at any time in history hasn't been guilty of this unfortunately
I'm not sure who this quote belongs to, but I heard it a long time ago and it stayed with me. Goes something like....
"Since the begining of time, land belongs to whomever can defend it"
|
| Posted 11/21/07 9:29 AM |
| |
|
| Pages: [1] 2 |
