LIFamilies.com - Long Island, NY


RSS
Articles Business Directory Blog Real Estate Community Forum Shop My Family Contests

Log In Chat Index Search Rules Lingo Create Account

Quick navigation:   

If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Posted By Message
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6]

oops123
LIF Adult

Member since 8/05

2509 total posts

Name:
michelle

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Im just reading this and had to tell you what I am presently going thru:
I sent my boys to a private school from pre-k to present (my oldest will be going into 1st grade in Sept) w/o much thought, because when we moved to the area we currently live in, my DHs friend's children attended this school and couldnt stop boasting about the credentials and it's reputation for acedemic excellence. The cost was very steep, but we had the same thought as you do: "nothing is more important than our children's education" - Well altho it is a wonderful school, I will be enrolling my kids into PS next september, for many reasons. First, I never bothered to check and see that my PS happened to be a great rated school....but the main reason is that there isnt a "PTA"in my childrens current private school, its instead a "PA":
teachers arent a part of the organization, and the "Parents Association" are extremely clique-y, if youre "in" - great, if not...you are left out of activities that go on in the school...and its extremely unfair,, I understand that I am not the only one to experience this, and according to friends who also have their kids in private schools, this seems to be more common than not.
The moms in the PA are all very good friends who went to the same school and no matter how "nice" you are, if you arent part of the click (ie.a wife of a doctor) you arent acknowledged...even w/in the group there is a chain of command depending on who's DH is highest ranking...and it is extremelely unfair. I send my children to this school NOT to make friends-honestly it doesnt bother me at all to not be invited to extracurricular gatherings and cocktails parties....BUT it does bother me when the same parents are voted to go on every school trip or in-class activity, and I am paying the same $ as they are to be left out of sitting in my children's class when it's a holiday or school event! Anyway this really gave me a bad taste for the school, altho the education they get is excellent, I cannot see myself dealing with this same bunch from now til they graduate, I cannot stand the pretension and negativity. My Dh&I came from a catholic school education and we did just fine...and honestly, my kids didnt really need to know French at 4 years old-lol...sorry this is so long, but JMO....good luck w/your decision!

Posted 12/16/09 10:30 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Not worth it. To me, if you have even an inkling of concern about the price, you're not gonna be wealthy enough to fit in and keep up with the joneses at that school. Like so many other posters said, just being able to afford the school is the tip of the iceberg-- there's the whole lifestyle that comes along with that kind of exclusive setting, and you wouldn't want your child to be one of the "have nots".

Also, I have a lot of friends from childhood that did go to an exclusive private high school (I went to Catholic school too though it was not $$$$), and to be honest my husband, who grew up dirt poor and came from the public school system in an economically depressed rural area, has been more successful career-wise than any of them. So much of success comes from within the individual.

Posted 12/16/09 10:39 AM
 

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Posted by oops123

Im just reading this and had to tell you what I am presently going thru:
I sent my boys to a private school from pre-k to present (my oldest will be going into 1st grade in Sept) w/o much thought, because when we moved to the area we currently live in, my DHs friend's children attended this school and couldnt stop boasting about the credentials and it's reputation for acedemic excellence. The cost was very steep, but we had the same thought as you do: "nothing is more important than our children's education" - Well altho it is a wonderful school, I will be enrolling my kids into PS next september, for many reasons. First, I never bothered to check and see that my PS happened to be a great rated school....but the main reason is that there isnt a "PTA"in my childrens current private school, its instead a "PA":
teachers arent a part of the organization, and the "Parents Association" are extremely clique-y, if youre "in" - great, if not...you are left out of activities that go on in the school...and its extremely unfair,, I understand that I am not the only one to experience this, and according to friends who also have their kids in private schools, this seems to be more common than not.
The moms in the PA are all very good friends who went to the same school and no matter how "nice" you are, if you arent part of the click (ie.a wife of a doctor) you arent acknowledged...even w/in the group there is a chain of command depending on who's DH is highest ranking...and it is extremelely unfair. I send my children to this school NOT to make friends-honestly it doesnt bother me at all to not be invited to extracurricular gatherings and cocktails parties....BUT it does bother me when the same parents are voted to go on every school trip or in-class activity, and I am paying the same $ as they are to be left out of sitting in my children's class when it's a holiday or school event! Anyway this really gave me a bad taste for the school, altho the education they get is excellent, I cannot see myself dealing with this same bunch from now til they graduate, I cannot stand the pretension and negativity. My Dh&I came from a catholic school education and we did just fine...and honestly, my kids didnt really need to know French at 4 years old-lol...sorry this is so long, but JMO....good luck w/your decision!



Thanks...I see this kind of mentality even at the dance school DD attends...all the mothers know each other from childhood and it's a really tight knit group that I can't even begin to chip at. I can also see this easily happening at the school DD is attending....I'm not sure if it is a private school thing or just something that seems to happen naturally, but it makes me sick that the cliquey-ness still continues at our age!!

Posted 12/16/09 11:41 AM
 

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Posted by computergirl

Not worth it. To me, if you have even an inkling of concern about the price, you're not gonna be wealthy enough to fit in and keep up with the joneses at that school. Like so many other posters said, just being able to afford the school is the tip of the iceberg-- there's the whole lifestyle that comes along with that kind of exclusive setting, and you wouldn't want your child to be one of the "have nots".

Also, I have a lot of friends from childhood that did go to an exclusive private high school (I went to Catholic school too though it was not $$$$), and to be honest my husband, who grew up dirt poor and came from the public school system in an economically depressed rural area, has been more successful career-wise than any of them. So much of success comes from within the individual.

I don't have a concern about affording it, just more of a concern about what the attitude and kind of people my DD would be around. But yes, success does come largely in part from the individual, I agree.

Posted 12/16/09 11:42 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Posted by johnsae

Thanks...I see this kind of mentality even at the dance school DD attends...all the mothers know each other from childhood and it's a really tight knit group that I can't even begin to chip at. I can also see this easily happening at the school DD is attending....I'm not sure if it is a private school thing or just something that seems to happen naturally, but it makes me sick that the cliquey-ness still continues at our age!!



Yeah, so sick of the cliquey-ness. I live in a neighborhood where everyone seemed to grow up here and they all went to school together... there's a clear clique at the local catholic preschool I send DS to. I definitely feel like the odd girl out, not being from around here. You would think we'd be free of this crap in our 30s.

Posted 12/16/09 11:46 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

We have this debate at home everyday - whether or not to send the girls to public school, or scrimp and save to send them to the local jewish school that has some of the highest rankings.

We're starting to lean against private school, even though we could afford it. Personally, I'd rather put the money towards a house in a better public school district - that way my children will have the benefit of attending a public school (which I'm a huge proponent of), and at the same time, the money saved, and put towards a house in a better district as opposed to private school will serve as a long-term investment for us.

DH and I have talked about it ad nauseum - we both agree that it isn't the school that makes the child - it's the family setting, the ideals and the family philosophies that make the real impact. I know that my children will strive and succeed no matter where they are, whether public or private school, because of our home values, so I don't necessarily see the benefit to spending all that money for private school, as long as we're in a good district, and we enrich their curriculum ourselves outside of school.

And, to add, I personally prefer a setting that's more diverse than private school. But, that's just our personal preference...

Posted 12/16/09 11:49 AM
 

Lucky
Growing up fast!

Member since 4/07

12683 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Posted by nbc188

If I could afford it with no problems, I probably would send her if it was as well-rated as you say.



If funds were unlimited, I absolutely would send my child to the best school out there.

Posted 12/16/09 11:51 AM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: If you could afford it...would you send your DC to a top school that costs $$$$

Nope.
If I were that wealthy, that I could afford a school like that, I'd be moving to a neighborhood with an outstanding public school system.

Posted 12/16/09 12:04 PM
 
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
To send to school or not to send to school... Marcie 9/20/09 8 Parenting
If you send Benadryl into school or daycare CathyB 8/28/08 5 Parenting
Elementary activity to send home before school starts? My3Shmoos 8/10/08 2 Teachers
I dont want to send my baby to school tomorrow KPtoys 2/28/08 5 Parenting
Would you send your son or daughter to an all-girls or all-boys school DebG 8/12/05 77 Families Helping Families ™
What kind of school do you plan to/already send your kids to? CathyB 8/14/07 46 Parenting
 
Quick navigation:   
Currently 414393 users on the LIFamilies.com Chat
New Businesses
1 More Rep
Carleton Hall of East Islip
J&A Building Services
LaraMae Health Coaching
Sonic Wellness
Julbaby Photography LLC
Ideal Uniforms
Teresa Geraghty Photography
Camelot Dream Homes
Long Island Wedding Boutique
MB Febus- Rodan & Fields
Camp Harbor
Market America-Shop.com
ACM Basement Waterproofing
Travel Tom

      Follow LIWeddings on Facebook

      Follow LIFamilies on Twitter
Long Island Bridal Shows